Thor #303 (1981)
By Doug Moench, Rick Leonardi, Chic Stone
Background: Thor has returned to NYC after a prolonged period in Asgard.

Notes: Given his name, Angelo Simoni is either Italian or of Italian descent. Whether his promise to leave the church alone extends to giving up crime altogether is unrevealed. Similarly, it's hard to tell whether his donation to Father Coza and plea for forgiveness are genuine or if there was a little push by Thor.
The story touches on religion and on the impact that having a Norse god flying around in the modern world can have on the more religious people. This is something that gets discussed from time to time in Thor, usually with a message of tolerance and respect, and with the occasional mentioning of a power higher than even Odin. It's a theme that will rear its head again in the two-part Crusader storyline (#330-31) and eventually be central to the Reigning arc in Volume #2.
Something Silly This Way Comes: Simoni's businessman front suggests that the police are unaware of his real activities, but all it takes for Thor to find out is one phone call.
Review: I mentioned in the blog's opening post that Thor is one of my favourite Marvel characters, and for this reason I have a lot of TPBs collecting various eras of his history. This carried with it the all too pleasant problem of having too many stories to choose from for his first review on this blog. I should start with something from the Simonson era, surely. But then there's the Lee/Kirby era that introduced us to Asgard and to many crucial characters. And what about the De Falco era, with the Egyptian Gods saga? As I pondered and pondered, I was drawn to the brief, urban, grounded Moench period (to call it "era" would probably be an overstatement) and to this particular story, as it highlights a side of Thor often forgotten or ignored: his wisdom. Thor can be arrogant, boastful, short-tempered, but when well-written there is also a gravitas about him. A dignified, charismatic nobility of spirit that makes others stop and listen. The Miracle of Storms doesn't really display Thor's powers, nor does it offer any spectacular battle, but entertains by putting the Thunder God in a realistic situation where his openness and convictions help Father Coza more than his strength.What this story lacks in action, it more than makes up for with a mature script. Father Coza's crisis of faith comes across as genuine, and so does Thor's counterargument. The points get across without the need for overly preachy statements. In fact, unlike his boastful battle-self, here Thor says very little at all, letting his actions and charisma do the talking, but also leaving Father Coza freedom of choice. In avoiding to push his view too hard, Thor respects the intimate importance of the priest's inner struggle and allows him to make up his mind.
Without much action or need for dynamic panels, the art by Rick Leonardi is all about static figures and facial expressions, with mixed results. Thor is always pretty good and imposing, and for once the wings on his helmet don't look like they are about to fall off, but only a few close-ups are successful in conveying the inner struggle of the characters. More often than not, middle-distance characters are somewhat featureless, bodies are stiff, backgrounds down to a minimum. It's not bad by any means, but could have been better and the overall impression is that Leonardi isn't quite the right match for this type of script.
Final Verdict: A self-contained, mature story, a little hindered by the art. 4/5
No comments:
Post a Comment